[Poll] Swift Vs V3numb (Round 1)

[V3numb]

Swift Vs V3numb


Round #1 Voting Thread


Important

Voting will be voted upon using the GFX rubric (Click HERE for rubric and if you need definitions for the words click Here ), Failure will result in a non eligible vote.





Use this for a guideline:





Composition - Are both sides equal? Or does one side look heavier than the other (Does the left have more effects/objects than the right leaving the right side feel empty?
Negatives: All the effects/objects on one side.

Colors - Do the color choices compliment eachother? Are they monotone, or to saturated? Do they visualy stimulate you?
Negatives: Monotone, or to saturated, colors that contrast poorly.

Lighting- Is the lighting realistic? Is their shadows? Is their depth within the tag caused by lighting? Is it possitioned correctly?
Negatives: The lighting is not facing the focal, the lighting is not shining on the focal.

Blending - Does the focal appear to be part of the tag or on top of it? The focal should be part of it, blended into the tag as if it should be there.
Negatives: The tag doesnt feel whole, the render just look added on this no attempt or effort to make it match the background.

Flow - Does the objects or design follow the flow of the focals body, or the flow of the focals individual sections and or limbs?
Negatives: think of the objects as lines, typically going in a direction. Do the lines create an X? If the lines creat an X, the flow is poor.

Style - Is the style creative?
Negatives: Bland, lacking of creativity.

Depth - Does the signature feel flat? or does it feel like there is distance?
Neggatives: Signature looks flat, less action.

[V3numb]

G'luck @Swift

[X-Calibur]

So here's my vote I'm going to give marks out of 10 for each category mentioned above

First off swift

Composition - 6/10
Colors - 6/10
Lighting- 5/10
Blending - 5/10
Flow - 7/10
Style - 6/10
Depth - 6/10

Overall 41/70

Just a few comments on it for me and my opinion ..... Didn't like the earth being in the bottom left also the heads seemed lost and had no colour in them .....


V3numb

Composition - 7/10
Colors - 8/10
Lighting- 7/10
Blending - 7/10
Flow - 8/10
Style - 7/10
Depth - 7/10

Overall 51/70

Numb I liked the balance and the colours in yours but only thing I didn't like was how you have squashed there heads ....


Both are very good ...


Hope my vote makes sense and is fair to your rubric

That vote ok for you sir ......

Updated orginal post with my vote

[V3numb]

yup its great for the most, keep em coming everyone

I don't care about your rubix, so I'm not going to use it.

Swift, I didn't like the sig's awkward shape, and Hitler was placed weirdly (what a weird phrase). The text wasn't great, but to be fair there wasn't a whole lot you could do. You did a good job incorping the atmospheric theme, but I think some parts, like the swirl's at the top were done a bit badly. The worst part to me is the border, because there seems like there could have been quite a few options here, and I didn't feel the white top/bottom style fit in with this one.

V3, the world at the bottom is clearly the worst part. This is by far the worst blending you've done in some time. The world isn't really blended at all, along with the C4Ds floating around the sides. The blue in the world doesn't really fit anything else, and some random yellow stuff floating around the top corner wasn't great either. The sharpness of the renders was good, but you squashed them in, which really is a rookie mistake for someone at your level. The text could have been done on MS Paint.

Overall, a HORRIBLE showcase of each of your work. This is so far behind each of your levels, you wouldn't even believe they are from the same people. I understand that it was a difficult thing to do, but bad render placements and unblended parts are really not something that should be done when you can produce high level GFX. I think one wins pretty clearly here, but neither of you are a winner with it.

Swift GMV

[iiMAGE]

Holy Fukin Bonkers you two Lol!!!
When I seen these....No "When I seen these, I was like WTF" They both totally different styles but they both Dope as Fuk no lie!!!
Damnnn... I hate voting on shit like this But Fuk it Lol!!!

@Swift

Your Composition is Bang on as You kept A sold technique throughout your work.
"The only thing here im having Trouble with is the fact of the Incorporation of the Globe in it"

Solid from one side to the other..

I think the Colors could have been a Lil more Vibrant but that's just my Opinion.
Looks to me as If you started to Pull the color from the Left Side but went Fade to the Far right.."Maybe your intention?" Not sure but ok with the Color portion otherwise.
The lighting was decent no doubt, But you didnt follow with to many Breakthrough's as The overall Image looks Dull and in the Shade "Old" Again the Vibrant Colors I believe would have pulled this out of the Final Image.
Your Blending and Flow I believe was Real good homie, Not too much to criticize there So good shit Pimpin!!!!
Creative in Style?

Most Definitely...

The Depth of the Pieces within the Canvas are properly Portioned and Look Great...
Only thing thats Really missing is just that Extra Pop Feeling!!!

Overall It was Dope as Fuk Swift...
Keep doin what you do pimpin....

@V3numb

I will be back For your breakdown in abit!!!

Im hungry!!!!

No Vote Yet and Soon to be Updated

*UPDATED*

Aight So....
V3numb....
You Fukin Beast With your Artistic Mind There Lol!!!
The Composition was Illy as Fuk. You Incorporated everything In a Visible Manner.

"Well Placed From Right To Left"

Everything Looks Great So.......Ya
"Vibrant" The Colors are Fukin Dope homie, Well chosen and Well mixed!!!
I Like how it all turned out no doubt, So I cant Really Criticize you on the Section!!!
The Lighting is good, I honestly was Expecting you to be Even more Vibrant then you Already were here "But The Overall Lighting does match Your Piece"
The Blending and Flow

Ridic!!!!

Minus the Fact the Bush Looks like he has A Nose Toobie Lol!!!!!
Shits still Illy as Ever!!!
Style?

"The Boii Has That Graphic Swag"

Wtf was that V?
You Really didnt leave me with much to Criticize on You Fucker Lol!!!
Great Work Famz!!!

So There U Have It....
Great Job from Both Artists Here No doubt!!!
Good Luck to Both!!!!

[Mr-Felon]

Hmmmmmmmmmmm tuff call I like them both Honestly

[Wigsplit]

I'm gonna go with V3Numb because his stood out more than the other. I like them both, but Numbs had more to it, more life. If I need to come back n expo more, I will, but this will still be my vote. Dope shit from both tho.

---------- Post added at 03:04 AM ---------- Previous post was at 03:03 AM ----------

I did like the others font better tho.

[J u s T C]

I can't see the entry's.

---------- Post added at 03:04 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:02 PM ----------

nvm I see them in the embedded into the poll, never seen that before. About to vote.

[X-Calibur]

Get of ya Nokia browsing on wap then haaaa