Andre - for starters, please dnt underline your damn verse like that man it hurts the eye, second a lot of your punchlines were played esp the opener and the closer !! i mean they played upto the extent of being in the category of da feet/defeat bars unless they got any sort of personal (which can be factually verified) quality of your opponent in it. with that said i think ur best line was the hospital bed one but other than that everything else was way too played for me to consider it as much imo.

Bobby - you on wordplays now man :O wow :O you sure have improved way faster than i could have imagined but i am not surprised, loved the scatology play, the proctology bit should have been worded a littl more better for the punch to be more lucid, the opener was tight on the multi end not much on metphors tho, loved the depandability wordplay, but the final punch didn't work coz the definitively wordplay did not work for me, neat closer tho you almost have a GTR flavour in your bars now i say you should work with him and join his crew too he will be glad to help you out with the now only minor stuff here and there.

Overall i had a played verse on one hand and a more original with a little left to be desired in terms of execution here and there but with a few attempts that came through in a few areas as well. i would go with bobby here - 

Low 5 and a high 5 here.

Bobby, there were no real discernable attempts at flips, or conceptual relevance, or the fundamental structures of punchlines. You have a vague grasp on multi syllabic rhyming, but, it reads as though you're just saying words, as opposed to using those words to construct a punchline, by flipping a concept to develop multiple meanings. Andre, you have a seemingly stronger understanding of the structuring of a punchline. Though, they're rather basic, and lack a lot of the more complex aspects. My winner took this with a stronger understanding of fundamentals. 

Lovedddd my winners multis here there is no denying that. Dude has some really dope flow going and his punches were dope. Loser did alright but too hit or miss at times