I'm leaning towards Naegii here, he had the better punches. Both had terrible wording anf execution, but Naegii was more direct and actually attempted to attack his opponent with his bars. Whereas Jay had the more cyperish verse imo, not directing his attacks so his punches had less impact.

Honestly have no idea who to vote for. Both have lots of work. One dude not even rhyming and the other stretching out words that aren't hitting or making sense. Don't mean to be a tough critic but it true though. Fairs in keep grinding 

Gotta edge it to Naegii because the material was a little better